Jump to content

Gf won't tell me about her past


While the thread author can add an update and reopen discussion, this thread was last posted in over a month ago. Want to continue the conversation? Feel free to start a new thread instead!

Recommended Posts

Posted

She's the one that brought up that conversation in the first place. I was honest and told her she's my 3rd and how I'm only into long term relationships. As a guy, I was never into sleeping around nor getting drunk at bars. I see people who do that as immature and simply stupid (regardless of gender).

 

But when I asked her back the same question, she responded with an ''Wow I thought it was gonna be higher that's good, well sort of the same here, but that's all''. I asked ''What you mean sort of, I told you my number what is yours'' and she replied ''I don't wanna talk about it''. Ummm then why would she bring up that topic? Does this means I could have been dating one of those wild, party girls with a high number for 2 years all this time??? Otherwise why would she say ''sort of''? Ever since last week I haven't stop thinking about it.

 

Any suggestions?

Posted

According to modern sexual politics she isn't required to tell you anything though communication is the foundation of a healthy relationship. Good thing the law in places disagrees and if she knowingly infects you with a VD it is a crime.

Posted
She's the one that brought up that conversation in the first place. I was honest and told her she's my 3rd and how I'm only into long term relationships. As a guy, I was never into sleeping around nor getting drunk at bars. I see people who do that as immature and simply stupid (regardless of gender).

 

But when I asked her back the same question, she responded with an ''Wow I thought it was gonna be higher that's good, well sort of the same here, but that's all''. I asked ''What you mean sort of, I told you my number what is yours'' and she replied ''I don't wanna talk about it''. Ummm then why would she bring up that topic? Does this means I could have been dating one of those wild, party girls with a high number for 2 years all this time??? Otherwise why would she say ''sort of''? Ever since last week I haven't stop thinking about it.

 

Any suggestions?

Obviously her number is astronomical and can only be understood in powers of ten. If her past or her lack of communication is a compatibility issue then you should break up no matter how much time you have been with her. Her ability to tell you the truth about her won't improve with time. I'd feel she was untrustworthy and playing little girl games after this.

  • Author
Posted
According to modern sexual politics she isn't required to tell you anything though communication is the foundation of a healthy relationship. Good thing the law in places disagrees and if she knowingly infects you with a VD it is a crime.
That's one of the major reason I've always done my best avoiding loose girls. Part from that, I just can't stand people with wild lifestyles. Then again, I love her. Hard to think I would ever fall for that and not know it.
  • Author
Posted
Obviously her number is astronomical and can only be understood in powers of ten.
This is what I was afraid of. How would I deal with this if I'm not a manwhore myself?

 

Or do can people change?

Posted
This is what I was afraid of. How would I deal with this if I'm not a manwhore myself?

 

Or do can people change?

If you are only worried about the sexual partner component have you been physically intimate with her and do you have reason to believe she has cheated on you? If you have been regularly physically intimate with her, she hasn't left, and she isn't cheating then don't worry about it whether you have given her an orgasm or not. You are enough for her. You should want to physically please her since having a giving outlook is apart of being in a relationship but don't get paranoid about it. Most women are sexually dissatisfied and there is nothing men can really usually do about it. Yet the same women are still loyal to their men.

Posted

Find someone with a similar mindset, love apart from attraction is still a choice. Choose wisely.

Posted

Obviously you caught her by surprise when you revealed your number is low - but still very normal - and that you are not a man-whore. (As a female myself I say well done!!)

 

She was most possibly expecting your number to be much higher. I'd guess more than 10 (at least) so she could feel comfortable telling you her own number. Her big number must most possibly involve a lot of casual encounters given her evasive response. Now she's afraid to reveal her number because you'll think of her as loose. I'm guessing you do that already because of what she said, though.

 

Anyway, I find it totally unfair that she would breach the subject first and then back out when she was cornered. It's her right not to answer of course but she treated you differently and she managed to learn your own number. I think you should have another talk. Because fair is fair.

Posted (edited)

...or, her number is also low but higher than his.

 

Most men want a woman with lower numbers than theirs no matter how low his is.

 

If he said 2, he'd expect hers to be one. If he said 1, he'd expect hers to be zero. If his were zero, he'd lie and say 10 (ha ha).

 

Hers could be 3 or 4, but as long as it is anything close to his, he'll perceive it as an issue.

 

Interesting turn about though... I'm glad to see women digging into men's sexual history before getting involved with them.

Edited by RedRobin
  • Like 3
Posted

Sounds like she hates to say she was a slut. If she is not willing to be honest then tell her she can lie to someone else. Don't waste your time on someone ashamed they were a slut.

  • Like 2
Posted

It is probably at the very least double digit and that isn't low.

 

There shouldn't be such secrets in a relationship. Neither partner has the right not to share if they want to continue to be in a healthy relationship. As soon as the secrets and lies start popping up it is over.

Posted
It is probably at the very least double digit and that isn't low.

 

There shouldn't be such secrets in a relationship. Neither partner has the right not to share if they want to continue to be in a healthy relationship. As soon as the secrets and lies start popping up it is over.

 

You and the above posters can't speculate what her numbers are.

 

No doubt she has had the experience of telling men her number in the past and gotten dumped if it is anything close to theirs.

 

Men are huge hypocrites when it comes to how many partners a woman has had...

 

Men think it is A-OK to be a man-whore and when they finally want to settle down, think women should be ok with it, even if she doesn't share the same experience.

  • Like 3
Posted

Men think it is A-OK to be a man-whore and when they finally want to settle down, think women should be ok with it, even if she doesn't share the same experience.

I agree with that totally, but the difference here is that the OP is not a man-whore.

Posted
You and the above posters can't speculate what her numbers are.

 

No doubt she has had the experience of telling men her number in the past and gotten dumped if it is anything close to theirs.

 

Men are huge hypocrites when it comes to how many partners a woman has had...

 

Men think it is A-OK to be a man-whore and when they finally want to settle down, think women should be ok with it, even if she doesn't share the same experience.

Actions have consequences and people like what they like there is nothing hypocritical about that. I mean honestly if there are men that feel that way then they have their reasons why. Men and women have to account for their actions if that means because you were a slut or a player at one time and you have trouble with people you are dating because of your past then so be it.

Posted

Hell porn stars get married :lmao:

Posted
I agree with that totally, but the difference here is that the OP is not a man-whore.

Yeah I don't know what thread she is reading.

Posted
Hell porn stars get married :lmao:

It is like how little girls dress up like mommy to feel like an adult. They want to be what they aren't. In their case they are attempting to be normal.

Posted
I agree with that totally, but the difference here is that the OP is not a man-whore.

 

I understand. The OP's girlfriend did bring it up too. That is usually the cue for mutual disclosure.

 

The OP might try a different path to find out why she is reluctant to share hers since she was curious about his.

 

I still think it is quite possible it isn't 'high'... just equal to or higher than his and she is self-conscious due to many men's propensity for double standards.

 

In any case, if a discussion came up like that for me, and I felt uncomfortable sharing certain information about my life, I just wouldn't become intimate with him. I wouldn't continue hoping he'd stop caring about it.

 

I think is is good for people to share their list of 'dealbreakers' before becoming intimate. I can recall at least one situation where a man shared his dealbreakers with me and I refused to continue seeing him rather than tell him that I didn't meet one of his 'criteria'.

 

Of course, he wanted to know why, and I just told him we weren't compatible. Easy enough.

Posted

There is some really horrible advice and plainly bitter people in this thread.

 

~

 

OP, if someone you are having a relationship tells you they don't want to talk about something you should oblige and not make demands. Bring it up some other time the next time the subject comes up.

 

Or, you can act like an immature boy man over and over again with different women and learn the hard way... or possibly never learn at all and end up like some of the bitter bad apples on this forum.

  • Like 1
Posted
I understand. The OP's girlfriend did bring it up too. That is usually the cue for mutual disclosure.

 

The OP might try a different path to find out why she is reluctant to share hers since she was curious about his.

 

I still think it is quite possible it isn't 'high'... just equal to or higher than his and she is self-conscious due to many men's propensity for double standards.

 

In any case, if a discussion came up like that for me, and I felt uncomfortable sharing certain information about my life, I just wouldn't become intimate with him. I wouldn't continue hoping he'd stop caring about it.

 

I think is is good for people to share their list of 'dealbreakers' before becoming intimate. I can recall at least one situation where a man shared his dealbreakers with me and I refused to continue seeing him rather than tell him that I didn't meet one of his 'criteria'.

 

Of course, he wanted to know why, and I just told him we weren't compatible. Easy enough.

She waited too long so it should be over. Anything she says now could be a lie

Posted
She waited too long so it should be over. Anything she says now could be a lie

 

He chose to be intimate with her regardless. I'd say responsibility lies with both of them.

 

Anything anyone says at anytime could be a lie. No guarantees against that.

 

If you don't trust someone, don't sleep with them. Real easy.

Posted
He chose to be intimate with her regardless. I'd say responsibility lies with both of them.

 

Anything anyone says at anytime could be a lie. No guarantees against that.

 

If you don't trust someone, don't sleep with them. Real easy.

I know it would have been over when I revealed my past and she couldn't hers. There's too many women out here to be wasting time on one that can't keep it real.

Posted

what is the big deal? "she brought it up..." you say, let go instead of being accusing of her, if the men here think dumping is the answer

 

women will end up not screwing guys at all ever in case we are deemed "sluts" by boorish men

 

there is no male equivalent to the word slut

 

you men want hot but virginal at the same time - unrealistic

Posted
what is the big deal? "she brought it up..." you say, let go instead of being accusing of her, if the men here think dumping is the answer

 

women will end up not screwing guys at all ever in case we are deemed "sluts" by boorish men

 

there is no male equivalent to the word slut

 

you men want hot but virginal at the same time - unrealistic

Correcton: I want hot and honest:lmao:

  • Like 1
Posted
There is some really horrible advice and plainly bitter people in this thread.

 

~

 

OP, if someone you are having a relationship tells you they don't want to talk about something you should oblige and not make demands. Bring it up some other time the next time the subject comes up.

 

Or, you can act like an immature boy man over and over again with different women and learn the hard way... or possibly never learn at all and end up like some of the bitter bad apples on this forum.

She asked and he was honest, but when the question turned to her she wasn't forthcoming. What would you do since we are all so bitter Great One other than wait around for her to answer?

×
×
  • Create New...