What would you prefer, a stick thin or fat woman?

[Ross MwcFan]

This question is for the guys who don't like fat women.

 

Would you even prefer a woman who is so thin that she doesn't have any shape and her ribs are showing over a fat woman?

 

I know everyone's opinion is going to be different, but it'll be interesting to see what the majority answer is, or if it's pretty much 50/50

 

I wont answer since I do like fat women.

[Greznog]

I'd greatly prefer a stick thin one. All it takes to get a woman to gain weight is to get to feel like she can relax in the relationship.

 

Getting one to lose weight, now that's a mother****er.

[ThaWholigan]

Definitely fat

[Cracker Jack]

Fat. I've been more aroused by bigger women in my life than stick thin. Definitely not into the thin look. I need something to grab on.

[somedude81]

What's the definition of fat?

 

Are you talking about this

 

Or this

[Badsingularity]

I would prefer a little overweight to runway model thin.

 

My wife is thin, not runway model thin, just normal thin.

 

I never discourage her from eating or putting some fat on that butt.

[USMCHokie]

Stick thin.

[Pyro]

why does it have to be one extreme or the other?

 

I choose neither. I prefer in the middle

[ThaWholigan]

I think most would prefer that, but for the purposes of the extreme argument, I still choose fat over stick thin

[Necris]

Okay so we have a nearly morbidly obese woman vs a nearly anorexic Assuming they are equal in terms of personality I guess I would go with the skinny woman they both have issues but personally I find skinny slightly more attractive and probably more workable.

[madjac74]

Okay so we have a nearly morbidly obese woman vs a nearly anorexic Assuming they are equal in terms of personality I guess I would go with the skinny woman they both have issues but personally I find skinny slightly more attractive and probably more workable.

 

Actually you can be skinny without being anorexic. In fact skinny people can have some very sexy muscle tone. It doesn't mean they have an eating disorder it means they just take care of their bodies and don't shovel down McDonalds all day long.

 

I know plenty of skinny people who eat quite a bit and don't have an irrational fear of gaining weight....they just don't gain weight. I am one of them

[Necris]

Actually you can be skinny without being anorexic. In fact skinny people can have some very sexy muscle tone. It doesn't mean they have an eating disorder it means they just take care of their bodies and don't shovel down McDonalds all day long.

 

I know plenty of skinny people who eat quite a bit and don't have an irrational fear of gaining weight....they just don't gain weight. I am one of them

 

Oh I know that, but from the question I was assuming the crazy extremes where you choose from the morbidly obese woman or the anorexic.

[madjac74]

One hell of a metabolism.

 

Yeah I actually felt the need to gain weight because people made me feel like something was wrong with me for being skinny. If only I had known how stupid society was 20 years ago

[Imported]

If you're going to go to that extreme for "thin" women, than let's say that it is in comparison to women that are so fat, they can no longer move off their own bed. Talking 400lbs +++

[madjac74]

Oh I know that, but from the question I was assuming the crazy extremes where you choose from the morbidly obese woman or the anorexic.

 

I know what you mean and the OP was biased because he prefers fat women> Even his question was jaded..."Women who are so thin that they have no shape and their ribs are showing...or a fat woman?" no mention of the imperfections of said fat woman like "she can barely walk up a flight of stairs and she has more rolls than a bakery"

[Necris]

Anyway it depends on how extreme are we talking.

 

Ultra Skinny (I heard she actually isn't even wearing a corset)

 

Fat

 

I don't know what to say Fat

 

I personally like the skinny one better.

 

 

 

Or are we going for the more balanced normal route?

 

http://blackbeltreview.files.wordpress.com/2011/03/fat-skinny.jpg

[madjac74]

Anyway it depends on how extreme are we talking.

 

Ultra Skinny (I heard she actually isn't even wearing a corset)

 

Fat

 

I don't know what to say Fat

 

I personally like the skinny one better.

 

 

 

Or are we going for the more balanced normal route?

 

http://blackbeltreview.files.wordpress.com/2011/03/fat-skinny.jpg

 

I'm not sure what the OP had in mind but the three in the last pic are all beautiful in my opinion

[Necris]

I'm not sure what the OP had in mind but the three in the last pic are all beautiful in my opinion

 

Agreed. The one on the far left has those sexy curves going on as well, but I like all 3:D

[somedude81]

The girl on the right, is at most a few pounds overweight, but certainly not enough to even be called chubby.

[Necris]

Far right girl is the one I liked got my left and right all mixed up lol

[oaks]

This question is for the guys who don't like fat women.

 

Just to be clear, you're asking the guys who don't like fat women if they'll choose a fat woman?

 

Would you even prefer a woman who is so thin that she doesn't have any shape and her ribs are showing over a fat woman?

 

If she'll eat my cooking I'll take the skinny girl and I'll have her at a healthy weight in a few meals' time.

 

But, seriously, I don't want to date someone with an unhealthy weight problem, which could be at either end of the spectrum, and I'd prefer to date someone who leads an active / sporty lifestyle...

[Pompom]

I'm not saying one SHOULD gain weight, but a healthy relationship is one where one is comfortable enough to not freak out over weight gain and fear of abandonment. A relationship based on "stay pretty or I'll leave you" is one any self-respecting person should run away from, screaming and flailing.

 

Now since I'm bi-curious and enjoy eyeballing females, I'll engage and say I prefer somewhat chubby to boney. First off because I don't like the fear of breaking/hurting something when getting physical with a twig girl (hugging my friend's ex was always a scary moment), secondly because I like to have something cuddly in my hands, and lastly because I think it's prettier. For example, I like Snookie's appearance (that girl from Orange Trash Shore). I don't like saggy-fat, just as I don't like bones showing, but if the "fat" body is a tight one where everything is where it's meant to be even if bigger, I can still find it beautiful.

Admittedly, with men it's different. If he doesn't look like a Middle Eastern Jew from an anti-terror unit (dark, lean, rough), I say "Next". But that doesn't make others bad-looking, it's just my personal thing.

 

For example, if I were a man or full-blown bi/lesbian, I'd hit that:

http://666kb.com/i/c6jd2dlbldo57nu9m.jpg

Edited August 20, 2012 by Pompom

[MercuryMorrison1]

Damn tough question.

 

Personally I would go with the stick figure. I'm naturally attracted to ''petite'' girls anyway, but when I say petite I mean short and skinny and/or athletic. I've never been attracted to girls who were just down right boney though. You know the one's that are 5,7 and maybe weigh 90lbs sopping wet? To me that's a sign of poor health, and I think I speak for most people when I say unhealthy isn't generally considered a postive trait.

[yongyong]

The first one is def 'Average' in America.

 

 

What's the definition of fat?

 

Are you talking about this

 

Or this

[Ross MwcFan]

Oh I know that, but from the question I was assuming the crazy extremes where you choose from the morbidly obese woman or the anorexic.

 

I'm talking about a woman that you would consider as fat, and a woman that's as skinny as what I described.