What would you prefer, a stick thin or fat woman?

[Ross MwcFan]

why does it have to be one extreme or the other?

 

I choose neither. I prefer in the middle

 

Because I'm asking a question?

 

Why does it have to not be one extreme or the other? I'm not interested in knowing whether peopel would prefer a normal weight woman or a woman that's a tiny bit over normal weight.

[Ross MwcFan]

What's the definition of fat?

 

Are you talking about this

 

Or this

 

The first one.

 

But what I'm asking is when a woman get's to be fat in your eyes.

[Ross MwcFan]

To clarify, when I'm talking about fat, I'm talking about when 'you' consider a woman to be fat (I thought this would be obvious).

[Ross MwcFan]

Just to be clear, you're asking the guys who don't like fat women if they'll choose a fat woman?

 

 

 

If she'll eat my cooking I'll take the skinny girl and I'll have her at a healthy weight in a few meals' time.

 

But, seriously, I don't want to date someone with an unhealthy weight problem, which could be at either end of the spectrum, and I'd prefer to date someone who leads an active / sporty lifestyle...

 

I'm asking if guys who don't like fat women would choose one over a woman that is so thin her ribs are showing.

 

Just because a guy doesn't like fat women, it doesn't mean that he'd prefer one that is so skinny her ribs are showing.

[Eclypse]

If I had to pick... stick figure. Ideally, she'd be thin, but not emaciated. That's not hot. But neither is fat rolls. My girlfriend has an ideal shape for me. She's petite (90 pounds) but you can't see her ribs and she definitely has ass to grab on to. Great for me.

[Pyro]

Because I'm asking a question?

 

Why does it have to not be one extreme or the other? I'm not interested in knowing whether peopel would prefer a normal weight woman or a woman that's a tiny bit over normal weight.

 

because most of the world will end up with spouses who are in the middle.

[Radu]

This question is for the guys who don't like fat women.

 

Would you even prefer a woman who is so thin that she doesn't have any shape and her ribs are showing over a fat woman?

 

I know everyone's opinion is going to be different, but it'll be interesting to see what the majority answer is, or if it's pretty much 50/50

 

I wont answer since I do like fat women.

 

Would you believe that i would run the hell away from either of them ?

[stillafool]

I think the question should be anorexic or obese. Asking whether one would like fat or thin is too broad.

[Ross MwcFan]

because most of the world will end up with spouses who are in the middle.

 

That's got nothing to do with my question.

[oaks]

In addition to my previous comments, I'd also like to date someone who is reasonably happy with her body and doesn't hate how it looks.

 

My experience to date is that it's impossible to give a compliment to someone who hates how they look and, after a while, the self loathing gets to me.

 

(I'm using the word "hate" deliberately... I don't mean "mild dislike" which seems to be a common usage these days... I really mean hate.)

[pink_sugar]

To clarify, when I'm talking about fat, I'm talking about when 'you' consider a woman to be fat (I thought this would be obvious).

 

This is a hard one, since it depends on preference. My dad considers a 120lb woman to be "fat".

[Pompom]

If she's 2 feet tall, she is fat.

[Mr Scorpio]

Well, I usually prefer my own favorite food, but dog **** smeared all over it kinda ruins it. So I will say Ross MwcFan's favorite food. Was that the answer you wanted?

 

My guess is that he was more interested to find out if men who don't find a particular body type attractive would prefer the total polar opposite (e.g -- you don't like food that is too spicy, so would you rather have that, or food with no spice at all?)

[Lauriebell82]

I think my husband would say stickly thin, although he doesn't like both extremely thin women and fat women.

 

He would probably say stickly thin would be a little more attractive though.

[joanlynch21]

I would say it really depends on personal tastes. I prefer seeing women with some meat in them and not bony.

 

This question is for the guys who don't like fat women.

 

Would you even prefer a woman who is so thin that she doesn't have any shape and her ribs are showing over a fat woman?

 

I know everyone's opinion is going to be different, but it'll be interesting to see what the majority answer is, or if it's pretty much 50/50

 

I wont answer since I do like fat women.

[Sauron]

I would prefer one of each giving me a tag team BJ.

[IcedEarth]

Fat, I don't like thin.

[Eternal Sunshine]

If I was a man, I would prefer stick thin.